Categories
Magazine

The Ending of Everyday Life

From the Valparaíso photographs of Sergio Larraine. Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons

The Ending of Everyday Life

Anjum Hasan

Look out the kitchen windows and there’s a road going down to the cemetery, low houses roofed with red tiles on either side and trees, an impression of lushness even at the height of this hard summer, the hillock in the background wooded too, and topped with a mushroom-shaped water tower where half the town’s supply comes from. Ten years, more than a decade, it’s been the same: the house down the way on the left with the mud yard always swept clean and orderly bushes of rose, hibiscus, bougainvillea, many-coloured crotons, the custard walls matching the colour of the well with a grating on it, matching the low compound wall with a stepped top climbing down the incline of the road. The old lady who lives there alone sometimes potters outside, but mostly she’s out of sight.

Nothing much goes on out there, it’s so quiet. Sometimes a car or a bike will glide down, or a boy walks up in a navy blue school blazer, thinking thoughts. Vendors go by calling the names of an ordinary something – a bag of raisins, an ice box of fish strapped to a bicycle, a basket of leafy greens. The silver oaks and casuarinas around the cemetery keep guard; there also alternate the fuller trees of copper pod and giant crepe myrtle which is always the winner, all those sprays of glorious pink, the dull yellow never had a chance. Come All Souls’ Day the cemetery will be hung with garlands and visitors’ cars backed a long way up but that’s in November. For now, a mesmerising summer stillness. Some of the older houses make do with hedges still, no built boundaries, just roughly pruned ones of morning glory or the always droopy sleeping hibiscus. A bean stalk snakes over the next door neighbour’s roof tiles; they have a thriving kitchen garden. A white cat-walking cat on the level top of their wall. A blackbird taps on our mirrored glass, dawn, morn, noon, and eve, that orange-ringed stare imperious till it starts to sing its honeyed five-note plaint.

This holds me like a prolonged caesura, the picture in the kitchen windows. Mornings the garbage collector drives up, his vehicle blaring, to announce his arrival, some nation-building theme song about hygiene and health. He must chat. How hot it is, I offer. The weather has changed and going ahead it will change further, he says. His coffee bushes back in the hometown haven’t flowered but he is calm, always cool and collected. Other things he grows out there I don’t catch the names of because his tractor engine’s running and loud. It’s hitched to a trailer where the actual garbage collector stands to receive the full bins, his granite face chiselled into beauty – imposing forehead, prominent cheekbones. He wears orange rubber gloves and says nothing. The actor who plays the Tokyo toilet cleaner in Wim Wenders’ latest film is not a patch on this man, but they’re alike in their self-containment. The cleaner eats his sandwiches alone in a park every noon, utterly entranced by the simple rustling of trees and the play of light through them.

Look out of the living room windows, on the kitchen side, and it’s the same hump of a hill with the sky flaring in peachy brilliance when the sun’s just gone down behind it, electric lights winking in the fire brigade building up there in the almost dark. I don’t climb to the top these days like I used to, going past stock-still egrets in the marsh below. The route up has been blocked by new houses and the last few times I found the grassy summit littered with smashed beer bottles, empty rum and whisky quarts.

From these windows I look down on the house next door in the compound, divided into two small quarters, new folks in one half now, their two young boys on summer break from school, the smaller bullied all day by the older and all day following him around calling, big brother, big brother. I should really get to know them but am still thinking of the family living here till last year, a young couple with a little girl. Before the blackbird it was her, peeking into the kitchen to check on what Alfons and I had on our plates for lunch, hanging from the bars of the open living room windows, where I used to have my desk, to ask if she could have a go at my laptop. Play with you later I’d promise and she’d climb down saying: I’ll come back when it’s time to drink coffee. The phrase for early evening: coffee-drinking-time.

In this two-in-one house next door, a musical chairs of tenants, settling in with their meagre belongings for a couple of years, swept out at short notice. If I stand in the living room I can see the caulking in the roof. If I lie on the sofa reading the cries of outrage in the local tabloid at each new depredation against nature, I can hear the father of the boys on his phone. Where’s the money, he demands. The money’s run out to buy chicken and tomatoes, I told you there’s no money, what money, all you gave me was seven thousand. He talks like he’s trying to set some kind of record for how many times one might bring up that key word in a short chat. I don’t know what he does for a living but it’s something that involves taking delivery of large packaged cartons over the gate after dark.

We must work, we must work, I swear like some furious Chekhovian character, like Irina exclaims, her face suffused with the joy of having found a way out of their ennui, in Laurence Olivier’s film of Three Sisters. She means honest work, the sweat of the brow, while the men sit around aristocratically rueing they’ve never done a day’s work in their lives. When she does start off, at the post-office, she’s indifferent and tired. It’s not poetic work, she says. I have always imagined these hardworking neighbours of mine hold the key to the perfection of life. An old lady emerges from the far side of the house to fling down leftover rice and sparrows swoop down around her at once; the woman before her would light a three-tiered brass oil lamp every evening on her open threshold; the woman there even earlier told me once about which wild leaves on the wayside were edible and which not though they all looked the same to me. They must live in tight accord with the numinous, but I can’t see it, all I’ve got are these scattered clues, and bits of advice. Never have one foot out the door and one in when handing someone money, never miss turning your face to the temple when walking past it, touching fingers to heart and then forehead, never eat too many bamboo shoots at one go, never start on anything new in April, never get married on a Tuesday.

I think back on them all, see the gruesome turn they’re at – a train of broken images, not a story of eternal suffering. Here’s the father of the little girl, asking me for a cash loan to take care of his mother-in-law sick with cancer. There’s the drawn face of the woman who lives alone, doing the dishes in a small joint in town to get by, her husband having left her for another, and now her son decamped to the next town with his auto-rickshaw, wife and child in it. Here sits a gnarly carpenter confessing he’s short of work and describing the grasping relatives he’s long fallen out with. Outside a man who works as a shop-hand drags his fallen, screaming wife across the yard by her hair one evening and we’re all there, trying to stop him; he leaves off and threatens to hang himself from the nearest lamp-post. A laboratory assistant is crying on the phone on a beautiful winter morning, swearing at his brother who drinks and gambles and sends off their old mother to earn for him. A teenage girl is sitting on the stoop with her head close to a friend’s, sharing secrets; she will soon drown herself, it’s never revealed why, in the Arabian Sea. In the rain a young housewife cowers under the awning as the landlord swears at her and then strikes her cheek. A thief works a padlock in the dead of the night, makes off with whatever’s down there: some money, some gold.

Look out through the front windows and a good part of this small town set out in the valley, a chequered panorama under a sky that, whatever the season, is vast and interesting. The sky turns slowly, the valley is filling faster than a speeded up film: apartments where there were hillsides, medical college, law court, deputy commissioner’s office where there were hilltops, shopping malls where there were paddy fields, houses where there were coffee gardens, temples and mosques where there was nothing. I sit on the balcony some evenings watching swallows and swifts cross each other like airborne stuntmen showing off, talking to my mother on the phone; she says this country has gone to the dogs, she says eat an egg every day if you’re not going to cook chicken. Later, looking in the bird book, I see it’s wire-tailed swallows and Asian swifts.

Out walking I make repeated note, like a touchstone, of the great trees screening an old bungalow: sky-high jamun, enormous silk cotton, the fluff burst out of its pods hanging whitely on branches, the blown spume, words drifting up from some half-forgotten poem. At a bend in the road looking down over a green chasm with small houses standing out from its slope, I see the place where last year a bank of earth fell on three men, hired to build in the rains, and killed them. There’s nothing to show for it now, the same modest homes, the soft bark of a dog, and silence. I try to keep away these days from the town centre flooded with tourists. They stand around shouting out to each other about where to go, or cruise in their cars looking for a place to park, or arrive in mini-buses and pour out in time for the lighted dancing musical fountain in the park. They give the impression of a violent forward lurch, bent on taking in everything and full of the anticipation of being bored, but there is nothing except cotton candy sellers and a decent view over the hills, and they are over-dressed and bored.

* * *

It’s hotter than ever, the thermometer on the kitchen window frame touching thirty, the heat from the roof terrace above us beating down. No ceiling fans in this house, they were never needed before so Alfons gets one for each room. He calls out instructions while I’m on the step-ladder, slowed down by not knowing the names for things. With one hand align the fan’s whatever it’s called with the iron hoop in the ceiling, slip in the big bolt with the other hand, put in the washer, screw in the nut, there’s a hole in the bolt, put in the little length of doubled wire through it, take these pliers, twist the ends out. That way even if the motion of the fan rattles the nut it won’t slide off the bolt, that twist of wire will hold it in. It’s good to recall, here on the ladder, loosening the rusted screws in one sugar cube (I’m learning the sweet words) to ease out the copper wires, that things are either the right way or wrong, nothing ambivalent about the behaviour of the electrical. All fans working except one, we have to get the electrician to take a look; he opens up the same sugar cube and find that the chaps who did the wiring when the house was built bunched all the wire tips together there to cause a short circuit. How are things, I ask him, and he can talk as he works and he is fast. Prices of stuff going up and we’re short of water where we live, he says.

At the Friday market, where all the produce – brown eggs, little bags of measured out horse gram and yellow peas, bricks of dark jaggery – are laid out in baskets on the floor or arranged on upturned wooden crates, and the plastic bowls of green chillies, carrots, beets look Lilliputian, buying supplies are gangs of working men from the construction sites all around, gabbing in the sweet lilt of the north. What’s remarkable is their smallness, their coming from a stock that has eaten too little, generations of the underfed charged with the toughest work. The driver of the garbage tractor is from these parts though, his place called Saturday Market. A little town nearby is Monday Market. The other days of the week around about too, names from the time when markets travelled. But no roving shoppers now, there’s far too much where they are and not enough means to buy it all.

Alfons and I watch the new Aki Kaurismäki film about working people, his and brother Mika’s films are usually about working people. Working women and working men sitting in bars after work, listening to the saddest songs, or sitting side by side on sofas in sparely furnished rooms, saying nothing. Everything I love about their films is here. When they do talk it’s the usual sardonic comedy: I’m depressed. Why are you depressed? I’m drinking too much. Don’t drink then. I drink to cure my depression. That’s circular reasoning. What’s that? Alfons falls asleep on the carpet. I follow the characters as they love each other, lose each other, grow quietly desperate because they can’t get work or don’t get paid for the work they do, find each other again. How could you sleep through a Kaurismäki film, I ask him the next morning. It was the war, he says, and I know. The heroine listens to the radio, waiting for her man, waiting for something to happen, and it’s often bad news about the war. Why would the makers of these tough, poetic, utterly terse films want to bring into everyday life something as obvious as the war? Why would they do what they’ve never done: nod at history in this shallow way?

We go to get a pizza and run into our friend who has a phone servicing shop; he’s smiling but hurt. Washing the chain of his bike, his fingers were caught in the spokes as the wheels turned and the top digits of two on the right hand came clean off. The neighbours rushed him to hospital but no-one thought to carry the decimated bits along so it was impossible later to graft them back. My hands, he says, holding up the heavily bandaged fingers, my work needs these hands. The pain, I ask, trying to imagine it. I don’t remember the pain, he says. I looked at my hand and I was in such shock I felt no pain.

Look through the study windows and as always the vines of blazing yellow allamanda flowers droop over the whitewashed cinder block wall next door. Nothing happened but everything’s changed. The great-grandfather of that house, when he grew too old and bent to work in the garden, would sit bundled in a dark jacket on the rim of the well and stare into the valley, rock still. Lately I don’t see him there, he’s gone. But the house help, likewise old and bent, walks up to the house twice a day. She takes down the laundry and folds it, stacking it up in a neat pile just where the old man sat. She sees to the flower beds, comes out mop in hand to put it out to dry, pokes in the burnt up remains of a heap of dried branches; the ash will go into the tomato patch. Then she goes in again, probably to cook. Her movements are deliberate and timeless; I could watch her all day. I think of the first phase, when great-grandfather would shuffle about, the second when he didn’t move, and now this unremarked upon disappearance. And again that feeling of being held in a delicate pause, as short as the moments in which I see the tiny, jewelled sunbird drinking from their hibiscus blossoms. That old man’s working life – not so much ended as lost. We’ve thrown away the scales on which to weigh his experience and we’ve forsaken the measure to place against it.

But for now it’s summer, it’s summer. Avocados and jackfruit in every garden it would seem and mangoes too, one tree hung with specimens so uniform and so uniformly beautiful I have to stop and stare, half darkest green, half shading to pink blush. Then I’m in the new mall buying an electric kettle as wedding gift for the office clerk who lives with her mother in the far side of the two-in-one house, her second marriage after the first man died we don’t know how, and I’m feeling hot and breathless in the press of crowds and crush of goods. I look at the overflowing trolleys in the queue before me and silently question their fidgeting owners: you really need all of that? In Ozu’s old black and white films of life behind closed doors, after people have left a room the camera will stay there looking at the empty chairs and quiet windows, at things making shadows as if they had an existence too, quite free of us: small things, tidy rooms, silence. I want to be there but I’m here without wanting to, and also fidgeting. When the cashier hands the kettle to another youth to test it, I watch him make a hash of it and wish I could stop him: he unpacks it clumsily, fails several times to merely plug it in, pulls at the cord so hard the thing almost drops off the counter, puts it back all wrong so the carton bulges and cracks.

He isn’t meant to do this, his hands could be better for something else but I don’t know what because no-one wants to be plucking coffee beans, no-one wants to be making chairs, no wants to be waiting tables, no-one wants to drive rickshaws, no one wants to watch over the rice paddies, no-one wants to be running the old grocery stores or the newspaper stands or the small messes for workmen lunches, no-one wants to be their parents, you talk to them and they’ll tell you their college-educated children say, no way, and they agree. I should have gone to the dark little store on market road with wooden cabinets holding a mishmash of useful things. He might have had a kettle and he would have talked. He had his arm in a cast once, said he’d fallen from the roof while fixing something in the chimney, but only some way down to fifteen feet so it’s all right, if he’d taken the whole plunge of forty-three feet…Another time, he railed against workmen, said one could scream at them before, now one has to make an approach with folded hands, they will say they’re just stepping out for a cup of coffee and disappear for days on end, it’s all the government’s fault, for keeping the poor supplied with free rice. And I remembered the dentist said that too, and the retired officer from some department or the other who lives in the row down from ours, he believes the same thing.

Soon there’ll be no work as such: only making do, only half-doing, only doing poorly, only doing well to only be disregarded, and with that all the chaos of directionless desire and wasted energy. And one watches Hirayama, that genius of a toilet cleaner, with such sadness; he won’t be coming back; he reads Faulkner at bedtime, listens to Lou Reed and Nina Simone on cassette tapes in his van on the way to work, tries his best to say nothing even when talking, holding onto his solitude like it was a hoard of God knows what gold. He wakes every dawn to the very same sound: a broom sweeping away dried leaves somewhere in the lanes outside. And because this is everyday life we’re given that scene over and over again and we never tire of it: light of dawn, scrape of broom, eyes opening. I wake every pre-dawn to birdsong, the call from the mosque, Alfons opening doors. The order can vary: mosque, door, bird; door, bird, mosque. Sometimes the singer can make that God-invoking thing into a sweet cry of pain, oftentimes he’s truly, discordantly, terrible. Go back to sleep, I tell myself in the dark. Leave life be. In the morning Alfons will say, water’s running low, he’s been to the roof to check on the tanks, is anxious when the boys next door spray the base of their guava tree with the hose too long, then the flowers and the mint, then their father’s bike, then the older one will turn the hose on the younger. Please get them to stop he says, so I do. Then I’m in the kitchen frying onions, he tells me something I can’t hear because the pressure cooker shrills. My mother sends a message about the library book I accidentally took away with me and then posted back. It’s arrived but she’s not going to the library just yet because her fridge is making sounds like “a train running in slow motion” and she has to stay in and wait for the mechanic to come have a look.

I gaze through the kitchen windows at the electricity lines looping over the lane, at a woman’s hair streaming as she rides pillion on a scooter, at the old lady’s pale pink roses and she has waxy, blood-red tongues of anthurium coming up in pots too. It’s all there, it hasn’t changed. Everything’s just the same.

Anjum Hasan’s latest novel is History’s Angel. Her previous work includes the novels The Cosmopolitans and Lunatic in my Head, and the short story collection A Day in  the Life. She is presently writing a personal history of Shillong.

Categories
Symposium 4: Against Storytelling

“What Difference Does It make?” For and Against Storytelling via the Novels of Kiran Nagarkar

Krishna Exacts a Toll from the Milkmaids, from a Bhagavata Purana, circa. 1600, Bikaner, Rajasthan, Northwestern India. (Courtesy: Wikimedia Commons)

“What Difference Does It make?” For and Against Storytelling via the Novels of Kiran Nagarkar

Anjum Hasan

Kiran Nagarkar’s 1974 novel Saat Sakkam Trechalis – Seven Sixes are Forty-Three in the English translation – is a modernist collage: fragmentary, dream-like, sidestepping linearity and conclusiveness, its hero repeatedly coming up against the absurdity of middle-class life, religious belief, childhood terrors and, most recurrently, romantic love. The novel describes the interior landscape of a dissolute and moneyless young man in Bombay and Pune of the 1960s and 70s. Kushank Purandare loves women, one after the other or simultaneously, but the novel is not a love story: he cannot submit romantic or erotic feelings to conventions such as monogamy or ideas of permanence and responsibility. And so the refrain of one of his lovers – “What difference does it make?” – becomes a theme of the novel.

After this novel, his first, Nagarkar would not publish another book till two decades later, when the novel Ravan and Eddie appeared. The place of Seven Sixes are Forty-Three in Nagarkar’s oeuvre has usually been discussed in terms of language – he wrote this first novel in Marathi and then went on to write several more in English. And that move is seen as proof of his linguistic talents. On its appearance, Seven Sixes are Forty-Three was considered unprecedented: its Marathi was unfamiliar (one wag asked, on hearing that it was going to be translated into English, ‘But should it not be translated into Marathi first?’) and its discontinuous structure apparently befuddled early readers.

But what the focus on Marathi versus English obscures is how far Nagarkar also shifted from that restrained, jagged, rhetorical style of his debut to create the chatty if not voluble voice he used in Ravan and Eddie. In the latter, he seems to laugh off the searing angst that saturates Seven Sixes are Forty-Three to focus instead on the resilient, sometimes even joyful, pragmatism of those who live in materially much more impoverished circumstances. It could also be that the India of the early 1990s in which he was writing this second novel was no longer the country in which a character such as Kushank Purandare – the young hero of that first novel – might convincingly essay his brooding lyricism. Ravan and Eddie is set earlier in time – from the mid-1940s to the early 1960s – but in tone it could be described as an Indian English novel of the 90s – exuberant, larger than life and indubitably filmi in the resolve of its down and out characters to overcome life’s challenges. Other, similarly effervescent novels from the same period that come to mind are I Allan Sealy’s Trotter Nama, Shashi Tharoor’s Great Indian Novel, Mukul Kesavan’s Looking Through Glass and, of course, the fiction of Salman Rushdie.

Just two years after Ravan and Eddie, Nagarkar published a third novel called Cuckold and with this – a 600-page saga set in 16th century Rajasthan – he seemed to have reinvented himself all over again. If Seven Sixes are Forty-Three is remarkable for the naked, bitter gaze of its hero on all of life, and for Nagarkar’s subversion of the conventions of the realist novel, and Ravan and Eddie for the joy that makes cramped communal life in a Bombay chawl – or tenement – however desperate, seem like a poignantly funny experience, then Cuckold compels for its sustained attention on the inner life of a medieval prince in a register that is sombre, richly descriptive and replete with the most finessed emotional nuances.

The prince, the Maharaj Kumar, speaks to us, mostly in first person, in a contemporary English idiom that makes surprisingly immediate the complex political life of the kingdom of Mewar as well as his tortured relationship to his wife Mira – who would go on to become the popular poet-saint, Mirabai, a figure who has generally been thought of in mythical rather than historical terms. In Cuckold, there is none of the first novel’s doubt about the significance and purpose of human action. Nor is there any of the second novel’s spirited colloquialism and its eulogising of the allure of popular culture. Instead, the focus here has shifted to a consideration of the yawning gap between the public and the private, convention and desire, politics and love.

I will come back to these three novels which seem to have nothing in common, and I will explore Nagarkar’s relationship to storytelling and its opposite via a slightly closer reading of all three books. But before that I want to ask what storytelling is generally taken to mean today in relation to literature. There are two, possibly related but not always well-argued for anathemas that have given storytelling its contemporary appeal because it is meant to suggest an escape from them – one is the sin of boring people, the other the shibboleth of cultural elitism.

* * *

In 2015, I was speaking on a panel at a literary festival with the novelists Manu Joseph and Zia Rahman Haider. The theme of the discussion was the literary novel which Joseph, who more or less hijacked the discussion, unilaterally declared boring and alienating to readers. He did not provide examples but from his comments one inferred that the literary novel was the sort which won awards, sold poorly and lacked a plot, and whose authors were persistent apologists for unreadability. That his own novel, Serious Men, had won a leading award not too long ago and that it had sold well enough for him to make, for a time, a living from it, seemed to him to only cement his argument. Despite his vituperation, Joseph’s point seemed to be a simple and banal one – that is, the market decides what is worthwhile fiction and everything else be damned.

Joseph has, before and since, commented publicly on his distaste for contemporary Indian fiction, so I will use him as an example here of an attitude which – in being held by a practitioner of a genre he considers largely worthless – seems self-defeating. And yet it is not considered strange. Joseph’s views are seen as either worth agreeing with or important to dismiss but not paradoxical. Zia Rahman Haider did the latter during our discussion by upholding his right to cultivate his chosen aesthetic as a writer, even if this is not rewarded by the market. But rarely is it noticed that arguments such as Joseph’s imply a curious solipsism; they are an echo chamber in which each writer creates for himself the version of the novel that he has authorised.

Several other Indian English writers actively resist the very idea of Indian English writing. This embarrassment with the genre seems to have become intrinsic to it. For his part, Manu Joseph scoffs at those creators of so-called serious literature, and his charge is that this seriousness is a ploy for mediocrity. Those robust writers who have their ears to the ground know the value of storytelling for the masses, whereas only wishy-washy liberals disregard storytelling in the books they write mainly for each other’s mutual approbation. In a recent interview, Joseph said, ‘I have a grouse about what is considered serious literature. The way activists have created a reward system for unreadable novels is a crime against art. So when social frailties are sold in the form of novels, which don’t have any stories or anything – that irritates me.’

Probing Joseph’s views further, one finds that he equates moral seriousness in art with ideological obduracy. He has written against activism in art – the move to replace what is entertaining and interesting with what is merely empathetic to all points of view. There is certainly, here in India and elsewhere, a growing conformism regarding how and who to represent – and an ever-ready willingness to take offence on behalf of one or another cultural identity. (Joseph’s first novel, Serious Men, a hilarious account of the brilliant conniving of a Dalit man to secure a place in the sun for his child, was read by some as showing the underclasses and women in a poor light, even though it moves away from the victim narrative usually associated with Dalit lives to present, in strikingly aphoristic prose, a bracing anger.) But Joseph does not distinguish such policing of literature with what is or at least once was a liberal catholicity.

Why then this wilful neglect of the modern capabilities of liberalism? In the interview quoted above, Joseph points out that except as some lowly derivatives of the West, as Indians ‘we don’t know what we are when we’re modern.’ So here again a rejection of that very thing one is supposed to by definition be – a modern Indian. This is not an estrangement of the kind that Kushank Puradare is subject to in Seven Sixes are Forty-three, but a categorical, even cold-hearted dismissal of the possibilities of one’s own singularity and specific experiences as an Indian. Joseph’s next novel, Miss Laila, Armed and Dangerous, while shaped like a thriller and so, naturally, replete with storytelling, is also aimed at ridiculing both liberal ‘eggheads’ and hardened right-wingers. This is at best only mildly amusing; it is also indicative of where Joseph thinks storytelling can take us – if nothing has value then the only role left to entertainment is to take down everything.

To valorise storytelling, then, is to hope that something exists in literature that could distract us from our own emptiness. For such valorisation not just shuns the ‘activist’ taking of obdurate positions, it apparently also shuns the opposite – open-endedness, ambivalence, nuance, ennui, what Joseph calls ‘social frailties’. The discomfort with oneself as a westernised India, the fear of boredom, the alienation from the dominant currents of political opinion of both the left and right, and the belief in the ultimate justice of the free market – all these seem to come together in the propagation of storytelling, which now means much more than just the folksy longing for a beginning, a middle and an end.

To reject one’s modernity as Joseph does is a sentiment interestingly incongruous in relation to Kiran Nagarkar’s Seven Sixes are Forty-Three, even though, in the way that his character tries to forge his own meaning out of his relationships and his run-ins with poverty and cruelty, this novel is a search for a modern identity. What makes the search compelling is that it is not foreclosed by any of the available formulations regarding what is or is not Indian. Nagarkar – or his character Purandare – is truly fascinated by what it means to be human in general while also completely absorbed in day-to-day local reality. Early in the novel Purandare says to the ‘you’ he is often addressing – one or the other of the various women he has loved and left –

You see people. In groups, in countries, in societies. Indians, Englishmen, Spaniards, Germans, Chinese. And then Caucasians, Semites, Mongolians […] Perhaps your training as a sociologist has something to do with that. I see only human beings. As individuals. Isolated, occasionally in groups. […] At best, I am a practising human being. Nothing else. I don’t understand the Indian subcontinent, it doesn’t exist for me, it doesn’t worry me.

Kushank Purandare’s reading – and these names are scattered like clues through the book – seems to consist largely of European modernists like Haldor Laxness, Elias Canetti, Pär Lagerqvist, Jean Anouilh and Albert Camus. (In some ways, he is a completer nihilist than better-known nihilists such as Camus’ Meursault. Unlike The Outsider which, despite its hero’s anti-establishment outlook, follows the novelistic conventions of set-up, climax and denouement, there is no single crucial incident in Seven Sixes are Forty-Three. Nothing in the novel has more or less significance than anything else just as nothing in Purandare’s existence does. And yet this does not make him more passive or indifferent than Meursault. In fact, he experiences other people’s suffering more deeply than the unfeeling Algerian ever could.)

Purandare does not read these writers as an Indian trying to internalise the West but matter-of-factly; they come across as inherent to his environment as Hindustani classical music or the films of Satyajit Ray. If Manu Joseph is able to hold forth on literature without ever talking about actual books – literature as a series of positions rather than a history of texts – than Nagarkar shows the opposite tendency here in his interest in literature as an experience rather than an argument. But nothing in this experience is in the nature of an event – the word Amit Chaudhuri uses in his concept note for this symposium: ‘We lived in an ethos in which the event was of primary significance, and whatever was significant had to be construed as an event of some sort.’ So if storytelling hinges on event, then this novel is about incident, and the seeming randomness of life’s incidents. ‘It frightens me … to think what small and irrelevant things change the flow of our lives,’ he says at one point. When read against other modernist landmarks from the same era, featuring similarly introspective, dissatisfied heroes, such as UR Ananthamurthy’s Bharathipura, Vinod Kumar Shukla’s The Servant’s Shirt or OV Vijayan’s Legends of Khasak, one realises that Nagarkar’s aim is not so much to pose a central moral question to do with individual purpose and dignity in a largely hostile society as much as to play with form as a way of questioning life itself.

* * *

Nagarkar’s second novel, Ravan and Eddie, begins with an event however, a child’s birth, and on the night of independent India’s first Christmas Eve, so we can’t help but wonder what it might owe to that other, older ‘midnight’ novel. But it appears that this date has no special significance for Nagarkar. Whereas Salman Rushdie’s hero in Midnight’s Children, Saleem Sinai, is born ‘mysteriously handcuffed to history’ precisely because he is born just as India is freed, in the case of Ravan and Eddie, 1947 is little more than a chronological marker and the departure of the British makes no noticeable difference to the lives lived in one of Bombay’s colonial-era tenements, the Central Works Department Chawl.

Further, even though, like Sinai, Eddie is born in melodramatic circumstances (as his father’s dead body is being taken to the cemetery and before his mother can get to hospital), these two narratives are markedly different in one other respect. The mythmaking in Midnight’s Children Children is driven by the author’s project of merging history with personal destiny, while in Ravan and Eddie, the myths emerge from within the imagination of the two children. Saleem Sinai may delight for other reasons but he is never really allowed a child’s psychology whereas Ravan and Eddie slowly stumble up before our eyes. Nagarkar’s ability to speak and feel from within the minds of his child characters is brilliantly illustrated by the legend of Ravan, the murderer.

As a bubbly one-year-old, Ravan leaps out of his mother’s arms and flies straight from the balcony of the chawl’s fourth floor into the arms of aircraft mechanic Victor Coutinho down below. Ravan survives but Victor dies from the shock of the impact. His wife, Violet, spends the next couple of decades in grim mourning, and their two children, Eddie and Pieta, grow up fatherless and poor. Close neighbours Ravan and Eddie are thus fated to be enemies. The fact that Ravan as an infant in some sense ‘killed’ Eddie’s father is revealed to him only when he is ten years old. A little earlier, in a scene unrelated to this great revelation, he tries to persuade his friend Chandrakant Dixit to join the revivalist Hindu Sabha (in return for the bribe of a fountain pen and an illustrated story book that the Sabha leader has promised him). Hearing him try to lure his son, Ravan is shouted out of the Dixit house by Chandrakant’s father.

Sala, you bloody murderers of Mahatma Gandhi, yes, yes, you, don’t pretend to be so surprised, you murdered the Mahatma, you have the gall to come to my house and preach the gospel of the Sabha.

When he is later told he also did away with Eddie Coutinho’s father, he acquiesces though he has no memory of either of these events. Ravan will acquire fame among his peers as a murderer of both Gandhi and Victor Coutinho and this fame will occasionally become a source of power for the boy. Yet it will cloud his life and dog him till his adult years – a misunderstanding of childhood that has hardened into fate.

Ravan and Eddie nevertheless end up becoming friends because both resolutely believe that they are destined to be famous showmen. Imagining personal success in terms of success in Bombay’s show business is as crucial to this novel and its sequel The Extras, as ‘making it’ in, say, Charles Dickens’ early industrial London involved triumphing over impecunious origins and avaricious capitalists and becoming a ‘gentleman’.

This hope that films hold out – at least the Hindi films of the 1950s and 60s that he alludes to – is a humanist one: the underdog will make it, not just despite his rough beginnings but also regardless of his cultural identity. Ravan and Eddie are Hindu and Christian so the furniture of their worlds, as it were, is different, but this difference does not script their fates. This is in interesting contrast to a latter-day Bombay chawl novel – Joseph’s Serious Men – where almost everything that his anti-hero Ayyan Mani says and does hinges on his being Dalit. Nagarkar belongs to what Manu Joseph calls Empathy Incorporated, but this empathy is less sentimental compassion for the poor, more an expression of the same humanism that in his first novel takes the form of a youthful angst at societal injustices and conventions, and which, in Ravan and Eddie, makes joy rather than anger the key emotion.

Both these novels then are expressions of what has been called Bombay Modern. There is, palpably, the same modernist fascination for the immediate and the quotidian evident in, say, the poems of Nagarkar’s long-time friend and colleague in advertising, Arun Kolatkar. One is inclined to describe Nagarkar as a Bombay Modern rather than a Marathi one not just because he writes in two languages but also for his disavowal of an identity connected with any one language or ethnicity. He is also a Bombay Modern in his relation to the past. The urge to make the past contemporary, to revisit it not so as to reinforce any notion of prior, say pre-colonial, Indian glory, but in order to test its accessibility to us, is what drives Nagarkar’s third novel, Cuckold. One way in which he draws this medieval history near is through what he calls ‘an easy colloquial currency of language’. The characters in this novel curse with words like ‘damn’ and think in terms of adages like ‘Nero fiddled while Rome burned’. And as much as the historical particulars are clearly evoked, this is no costume drama or period piece.

Such contemporaneity does two things. It gives us a sense of the crown prince or Maharaj Kumar – the figure at the centre of the drama – from the inside as a passionately preoccupied figure, bedevilled by doubts, intelligent, sensuous and lonely. And it brings alive the dynamism of the period being described. The Kumar, even as he is trying to rein in his Krishna-besotted wife and win wars for Mewar, is engrossed in questions to do with the foolishly anachronistic aspects of Rajput chivalry. He is a man of the moment and this is not a timeless kingdom of yore but one caught in a many-pronged conflict featuring older Muslim rulers in north India, such as the Khiljis and the Lodis, the first Mughal, Babur, and the several other neighbouring Hindu states.

This is a situation which seems to call for not just new ways of fighting wars but also new definitions of the self. In an epiphanic passage, the prince talks of how he had gods for heroes as a child but when he grew up he realised the gods are implacable. ‘Their lives were turbulent but the quality of their experience rarely warped, bent or changed the way they looked at things. Their minds were impervious. Little, if anything, seeped in.’

And that is the critical contrast: the ever shifting situation of the mortals versus the timeless nature of the gods. Perry Anderson, in his essay on historical fiction published in the London Review of Books some years ago, described Giuseppe Lampedusa’s 1960 novel Leopard as ‘the greatest historical novel of the century’ for its interlocking, rare in general for the genre, of the historical and existentialist registers. Cuckold manages to do the same – it is an existential novel about life as a Rajput prince in the 1500s or, conversely, a historical novel about the sorrow of being in an incompatible marriage and living in an unsympathetic realm. In a recent interview, Nagarkar said that after he finished the novel, he remembers telling his partner that everything in it was true. (This is interesting to consider alongside his remark, in the afterword to the novel, that ‘The last thing I wanted to do was write a novel of historical veracity.’) He goes on to say in the interview that by ‘true’ he means that he was striving for not historical but ‘artistic authenticity’.

What could that imply in relation to an epic work of storytelling? Moving beyond both event and incident, I want to go back to a word I used a little earlier – situation. The situation, in Cuckold and in Nagarkar’s other novels, is the human one. Nagarkar’s experiments with different forms and styles in these three novels – and his ability to incorporate both high and low registers – is evidence of writerly virtuosity but it also suggests a restless search for the perfect vehicle to express this artistic authenticity in the cause of his humanism. If the propagation of storytelling furthers the myth that everyone is potentially a storyteller, and so literature is indistinguishable from life, then Nagarkar shows how much art must be brought to bear on the question of which stories are worth telling.

But if the novel’s art is considered a way of thinking of moral problems practically, through narrative, then Kiran Nagarkar does tell stories. I am drawing on Susan Sontag here, who in her essay, ‘At the Same Time’, discusses how the delineation of borders in the novel, its essentially limited and particular structure, its inevitable setting in a particular time and space, subverts that bizarre reality engendered by globalisation and globalised media of a constant now and an always here. And this is what distinguishes literature from the stories the media tells.

By presenting us with a limitless number of non-stopped stories, the narratives which the media relate—the consumption of which has so dramatically cut into the time the educated public once devoted to reading—offer a lesson in amorality and detachment that is antithetical to the one embodied by the enterprise of the novel.

Here then is an argument for storytelling, which is that it is an ethical act and its ethics consists in taking responsibility for selection and providing insight through closure or completion. Sontag rejects the ‘spurious cultural geography of a borderless world’, and Kiran Nagarkar in being at once a storyteller and against storytelling is able to make the worlds of his novels both scrupulously particular and widely resonant.

Anjum Hasan is the author of a book of poetry and several works of fiction. Her new novel History’s Angel is out from Bloomsbury in July.